Skip to content
Home » Blog » Phlebotomist vs. CNA

Phlebotomist vs. CNA

  • by

With the recent explosion in healthcare job opportunities, many people have started exploring ways to break into the field. Two popular entry-level healthcare jobs are certified nursing assistants (CNAs) and phlebotomists. While both positions offer a foot in the door and opportunities for advancement, there are some key things to think about before you make your decision.

What are the differences in responsibilities between phlebotomists and CNAs? Let’s dive into the distinct responsibilities of these roles and uncover the differences.

Phlebotomists: Mastering the Art of Blood Collection

Phlebotomists specialize in the precise art of blood collection and handling. Armed with expert knowledge and technical skills, these professionals are adept at drawing blood samples from patients. They ensure a comfortable and safe experience, maintaining strict adherence to sanitary protocols. With precision and efficiency, phlebotomists collect blood specimens, label them accurately, and carefully transport them to the laboratory for analysis. Their keen eye for detail and mastery of venipuncture techniques makes them indispensable members of the healthcare team.

Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs): Compassionate Caregivers at the Frontline

CNAs, on the other hand, excel in providing compassionate and direct patient care. They are at the frontline of healthcare, assisting patients with various activities of daily living. From bathing and dressing to assisting with mobility and feeding, CNAs play a vital role in ensuring patients’ comfort and well-being. They also take and record vital signs, observe patients for any changes in health, and communicate important information to the healthcare team. CNAs often forge close bonds with patients, providing emotional support and lending a caring hand during challenging times.

Distinct Responsibilities, Converging Objectives

While phlebotomists focus primarily on blood collection and specimen handling, CNAs prioritize direct patient care and support. However, their roles intersect in providing quality healthcare to patients. Phlebotomists may encounter patients during blood draws and must exhibit empathy and clear communication skills to establish trust and alleviate fears. CNAs, in turn, may assist phlebotomists by preparing patients for blood collection, ensuring their comfort and cooperation.

Certification process: CNA vs. phlebotomist

Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) and phlebotomy certifications differ in their respective processes. CNAs undergo state-approved education, clinical training, and a certification exam to ensure compassionate care. Phlebotomy certifications focus on specialized training in blood collection, encompassing education, hands-on practice, and a certification exam. Technology aids in accessible resources, virtual training, and streamlined processes. Both certifications open doors to fulfilling healthcare careers.

Becoming a CNA involves a comprehensive certification process focused on equipping individuals with the skills to provide compassionate and effective care. Typically, the process includes the following steps:

  1. Education and Training: Aspiring CNAs enroll in state-approved CNA programs or vocational schools. These programs combine theoretical knowledge with hands-on clinical training, covering topics such as basic nursing skills, patient safety, infection control, and communication techniques.
  2. Clinical Experience: CNAs gain practical experience through supervised clinical rotations in healthcare settings. These hands-on experiences provide opportunities to apply learned skills in real-life scenarios while working under the guidance of experienced professionals.
  3. Certification Exam: Once the educational requirements are met, candidates must pass a state-approved certification exam. The exam assesses their knowledge and competency in areas such as patient care, safety measures, and ethical considerations.

Phlebotomy, the art of drawing blood, requires specialized skills and precision. Certification in phlebotomy signifies expertise in this field. Here’s an overview of the typical certification process:

  1. Education and Training: Prospective phlebotomists can pursue formal training through accredited phlebotomy programs or vocational schools. These programs cover essential topics such as venipuncture techniques, specimen handling, anatomy, and infection control.
  2. Hands-on Practice: Practical training is a crucial component of phlebotomy certification. Students get ample opportunities to practice venipuncture techniques and develop the necessary skills for successful blood collection. The training may involve supervised clinical rotations or externship programs in healthcare facilities.
  3. Certification Exam: After completing the required education and training, individuals must pass a certification exam to become certified phlebotomists. The exam typically evaluates their knowledge of phlebotomy procedures, safety protocols, specimen handling, and relevant regulations.

Where do CNAs and phlebotomists work?

CNAs and phlebotomists work in various healthcare settings, contributing to patient care in unique ways. Here are the typical work environments for each profession:

Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs)

  1. Nursing Homes/Long-Term Care Facilities: CNAs often work in nursing homes or long-term care facilities, providing daily assistance to elderly or chronically ill residents.
  2. Hospitals: Many CNAs find employment in hospitals, assisting nurses with patient care, monitoring vital signs, and supporting daily activities.
  3. Assisted Living Facilities: CNAs may work in assisted living facilities, helping residents with personal care, medication management, and daily living tasks.
  4. Home Health Agencies: CNAs can provide in-home care, supporting individuals with personal hygiene, mobility, and light housekeeping.


  1. Hospitals/Clinics: Phlebotomists commonly work in hospitals or medical clinics, performing blood draws and collecting samples from patients.
  2. Diagnostic Laboratories: Phlebotomists may be employed in diagnostic laboratories where they handle blood samples, ensuring accurate labeling and proper storage.
  3. Blood Banks: Some phlebotomists work in blood banks, where they collect blood donations and ensure donor safety.
  4. Research Facilities: Phlebotomists can be found in research settings, assisting with blood collection for studies and clinical trials.

Both CNAs and phlebotomists contribute to the healthcare industry, providing essential care and support in diverse healthcare settings.

Who gets paid more, phlebotomists or CNAs?

When it comes to salaries, phlebotomists generally have a slightly higher median pay compared to CNAs. Phlebotomists’ specialized skills in blood collection contribute to their slightly higher earning potential. However, factors like location, experience, certifications, and the healthcare setting can influence salary variations. CNAs, while crucial in direct patient care, may have a slightly lower median salary range. It’s important to consider the demand and regional factors impacting compensation.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics data from their most recent report published in May 2023, the average salary for each profession was:

  • Phlebotomists: $37,380
  • CNAs: $36,220

See phlebotomy salaries by state and how much does a CNA make?

Job outlook: Phlebotomists vs. CNAs

Certified Nursing Assistants and phlebotomists both have promising job prospects in the healthcare industry. Here’s a concise breakdown of their respective job outlooks:

CNAs: Steady Demand

  • Increasing demand due to the aging population and the need for long-term care services.
  • Growth in home healthcare services contributes to more opportunities for CNAs.
  • Efforts to improve healthcare access further boost demand for CNAs.

Phlebotomists: Tapping into Opportunities

  • Advancements in diagnostic testing drive the need for skilled phlebotomists.
  • Growing healthcare facilities, such as hospitals and clinics, require more phlebotomists.
  • Specialized services, like pediatric or geriatric phlebotomy, offer additional opportunities.

Technology and Innovation: Shaping the Future

  • Technology plays a significant role in healthcare, impacting both CNAs and phlebotomists.
  • Electronic health records (EHRs) and mobile health applications streamline workflows.
  • Familiarity with healthcare technology enhances employment prospects.

Both CNAs and phlebotomists can anticipate favorable job outlooks. The demand for compassionate CNAs remains steady, driven by demographic shifts and evolving care preferences. Phlebotomists benefit from advancements in diagnostics and expanding healthcare facilities. Embrace the opportunities at the intersection of technology and healthcare for a rewarding career.